The Voluntary Sector Initiative is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Top 10 Christian Cookie Cutters of 2020 – Consumer Guide & Reviews

Rank No. #1
Baptism First Communion and Confirmation Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters, Set of 6
  • Material - Stainless Steel
  • Size - 3 1/4 Inch (H) - 5 1/4 Inch (H)
  • Includes 1 Each of a Church, Chalice, Cross, Angel, Dove, and Lamb Design
  • Care Instructions - Cookie Cutters are Not Dishwasher Safe. Always hand Wash with Soap and Warm Water. After Washing, Shake off Excess Water and Then Place Cookie Cutters in a Warm Oven. This Will Quickly Dry Off Any Left Over Moisture. Store in a Cool, Dry Place.
  • These are Perfect for Celebrating Any Sacrament and Make a Fun Activity to Do With Children
Rank No. #2
Christian Bible Study Cookie Cutter 6 Piece Set from The Cookie Cutter Shop - Cross, Dove, Church, Plaque, Bible, Christian Fish Cookie Cutters – Tin Plated Steel Cookie Cutters
  • Christian Bible Study Cookie Cutter 6 Piece Set; Each cookie cutter is made from tin plated steel and is food grade certified. Each has rolled edges on top making it safe and comfortable to handle. They all have a sharp bottom which allows for accurate cutting that creates impressive results.
  • Set Includes: 3.5 inch Cross, 3.5 inch Dove, 4 inch Church, 4 inch Plaque, 4.25 inch Bible, 4.25 inch Christian Fish; Each are heavy-duty tested and certified food-grade tin plated steel
  • Our cookie cutters are perfect for so many projects. They are great for cutting cookie dough, brownies, cakes, fondant, soft fruits, vegetables, bread, cheese, sandwiches and craft clay. In addition, use your cookie cutters as a pancake mold or in the classroom as drawing tools. The possibilities are endless!
  • Use our Christian Bible Study Cookie Cutter 6 Piece Set to bake some delicious cookies and decorate them to server at birthday parties, weddings, summer picnics, church or school functions, bake sales or to your family and friends.
  • Cookie Cutter Care – After using your cookie cutters, hand wash and towel dry them. Then place them on a clean cookie sheet in your oven as it cools down from baking. The heat will dry out any remaining water that you may have missed from towel drying. Tin plated steel cookie cutters are NOT Dishwasher Safe.
Rank No. #3
Jesus Cookie Cutter
  • Food Safe Material
  • Superior Quality
  • Strong Wall Thicknesses
  • Sharp Cutting Edges
  • Durable and Reusable
Rank No. #4
LILIAO Chalice Cookie Cutter Holy Cup Christian Baptism Fondant Biscuit Cutter - 2.3 x 4.1 inches - Stainless Steel
  • Size: 2.3 x 4.1 inches, 1 inch deep cut. perfect for Christian baptism.
  • Made from Food Safe Stainless Steel.
  • Not only perfect for cutting cookie dough, but also for cutting fondant, bread, sandwiches, jelly, cheese, soft fruits, pancake, soap, craft clay.
  • Smooth cutting edge makes them easy to use for adults and kids, the other side for press is binding processed, makes them safety to use.
  • Stainless steel material, not easy to get rust, very durable and dishwasher safe.
Rank No. #5
3 Pcs, Cross Cookie Cutter, Baptism Cookie Cutter, Religious Cookie Cutters, Cookie Cross, Cookie Cutters Cross Shape, Christian Cookie Cutters, Biscuit Cutter, Polymer Clay Cutters, Fondant Tools
  • 【Cross Cookie Cutters Good Quality 】 Cross mold high quality of food grade stainless steel, not contain BPA. The simple stainless steel design is easy to clean, and folded edges are kind to hands, Use safety and comfort.
  • 【Super Value Cross Cookie Cutter】 3 different shapes and sizes. Cross molds give you more options.
  • 【Simple And Extensive Use Easter Cookie Cut Outs】Just press the baptism cookie cutter, and you can get a pattern you want. 3 cookie cutter can be used for sugar cake, DIY biscuits, chocolate, mini pie, cookie fruit and vegetables, into multiple shapes with these cutter molds, make meal time fun.
  • 【Nativity Cookie Cutters Shapes, Reusable And Easy To Clean】The dishwasher is safe and can be cleaned with soap. It is recommended to dry after use and pay attention to drying. Christian cookie cutters can prevent rusting and prolong service life.
  • 【Large Cookie Cutters, Good choice of gifts】Decorate your food and make her look more delicious with baptism cookie cutter set. A great way to encourage your children to be involved in food. If metal cookie cutter is any problems, contact us without hesitation for free replacement.
Rank No. #6
6 Pcs, Angel Cookie Cutter, Cookie Cutter Angel, Cross Cookie Cutter, Baptism Cookie Cutters, Angel Fondant Cutter, Christian Cookie Cutters, Polymer Clay Cutters, Fondant Tools, Clay Cutters
  • Angel Cookie Cutter Good quality : high quality of food grade stainless steel,not contain BPA,The simple stainless steel design is easy to clean,and folded edges are kind to hands,Use safety and comfort.
  • Super value cross cutter cookie : 6 different shapes and sizes. Give you more options
  • Simple and extensive use:Just press the angel mold, and you can get a pattern you want.It can be used for sugar cake,DIY biscuits,chocolate,mini pie,cookie fruit and vegetables,into multiple shapes with these cutter molds, make meal time fun.
  • Reusable and easy to clean:The dishwasher is safe and can be cleaned with soap. It is recommended to dry after use and pay attention to drying. Angel fondant cutter can prevent rusting and prolong service life.
  • Good choice of gifts: Decorate your food and make her look more delicious with baptism cookie cutter set.a great way to encourage your children to be involved in food.If there is any problems, contact us without hesitation for free replacement.
Rank No. #7
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters 3-Piece Religious Christmas Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet, Angel, Cross and Dove
  • Pay homage to your faith or make treats for a special religious event.
  • Made in the USA; Manufactured in America with certified food safe American steel
  • Variety; For over 30 years the Clark Family has specialized in original designs for creative baking
  • Baking and Party Supplies; Cut, mold and decorate themed shapes for any holiday, party or event
  • Create; Make fun shapes with cookie dough, fondant, biscuits, brownies, cakes, or craft clay
Rank No. #8
Nativity Story Set of 12 Stainless Steel Cookie Cutter Set
  • Lighthouse Christian Products Nativity Cookie Cutter set is perfect for Christmas Baking
  • Set includes 12 different cookie cutters: Mary, Joseph, Jesus, the manger, one wiseman, one shepherd, an angel, a camel, a sheep, a donkey, a star, and a heart.
  • Made of stainless steel; Features devotional notes that talk about the meaning of each cookie cutter
  • Measures approximately 12 Piece Inches; Perfect for decorative display or functional use around the holidays; Great for counting down the days until Christmas
  • Your purchase helps support orphans and children with special needs in Ghana, Africa
Rank No. #9
4.3 inch Angel Cookie Cutter – Stainless Steel
  • 1 PIECE ANGEL COOKIE CUTTERS - Present our 1-piece popular angel shapes cookie cutter. Use it for Christmas/Batism/Christening themed party. Use the shapes to create seasonal story!
  • Product includes: Angel( 4.3 inch tall x 4.3 inch wide x 1 inch deep )
  • Material: Stainless steel, durable, sturdy and dishwasher safe.
  • Used: not only use at party or holiday, but also use for cutting pancake, cheese, craft clay, jelly and soft fruits.
  • We are a small business. Keewah is the idea of two boys who loved the various shapes of cookie cutters coming from their father’s factory. When they grew up, they were inspired to create even more fun shapes to share with everyone.
Rank No. #10
LILAO Fish Cookie Cutter for Christian Baptism - 4.1 x 1.6 inches - Stainless Steel
  • Perfect for making some cookies for a Christian Baptism
  • Made from Food Safe Stainless Steel.
  • Not only perfect for cutting cookie dough, but also for cutting fondant, bread, sandwiches, jelly, cheese, soft fruits, pancake, soap, craft clay.
  • Smooth cutter edge makes them easy to use for adults and kids, the other side for press is binding processed, makes them safety to use.
  • Stainless steel material, not easy to get rust, very durable and dishwasher safe.
Rank No. #11
LILIAO Large Fancy Cross Cookie Cutter Christian baptism Fondant Biscuit Cutter - 3.3 x 4.4 inches - Stainless Steel
  • Size: 3.3 x 4.4 inches, 1 inch deep cut. perfect for Christian baptism.
  • Made from Food Safe Stainless Steel.
  • Not only perfect for cutting cookie dough, but also for cutting fondant, bread, sandwiches, jelly, cheese, soft fruits, pancake, soap, craft clay.
  • Smooth cutting edge makes them easy to use for adults and kids, the other side for press is binding processed, makes them safety to use.
  • Stainless steel material, not easy to get rust, very durable and dishwasher safe.
Rank No. #12
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Bethlehem Star Cookie Cutter, 5"
  • Embrace the spirit of Christmas with the Star of Bethlehem Cookie Cutter.
  • Made in the USA; Manufactured in America with certified food safe American steel
  • Variety; For over 30 years the Clark Family has specialized in original designs for creative baking
  • Baking and Party Supplies; Cut, mold and decorate themed shapes for any holiday, party or event
  • Create; Make fun shapes with cookie dough, fondant, biscuits, brownies, cakes, or craft clay
Rank No. #13
4 Pieces Holy Cross Shaped Cookie Cutter Fondant Decoration Ideas Christian Cookie Cutters Set Halloween Baking Supplies
  • MATERIAL: Stainless steel.
  • PACKAGE: 4pcs Kinds of stainless steel cross cutters molds.
  • SIZE: 3.54x2.48x0.78inches.
  • WIDE RANGE OF USES: Perfect Sunday school gift supplies, great to make your favorite cookies, treats, ornaments or crafts for holidays, parties and other special occasions with these cross cookie cutters. Make the most of your imagination. The four styles of cross cookie cutters can meet your more baking needs.
  • NOTICE: The metal is soft, if the cross shaped cookie cutter is deformed during the transportation, you can regain the original slowly and easily.
Rank No. #14
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Angel Cookie Cutter, 3.75"
  • This Angel Cookie Cutter will be a delight for all ages, whether it's on the tree or utilized in your kitchen.
  • Made in the USA; Manufactured in America with certified food safe American steel
  • Variety; For over 30 years the Clark Family has specialized in original designs for creative baking
  • Baking and Party Supplies; Cut, mold and decorate themed shapes for any holiday, party or event
  • Create; Make fun shapes with cookie dough, fondant, biscuits, brownies, cakes, or craft clay
Rank No. #15
Fox Run Easter Cookie Cutter Set, 4-Piece
  • Set of 4 tinplated cookie cutters - 3-inch
  • Easter shapes include: bible, church, lamb and cross
  • Great to use with kids for making cookies for the easter holiday
  • Great gift idea
  • Perfect addition to any kitchen
Rank No. #16
Nativity Cookie Cutter 7 Pc Set – Joseph, Mary, Manger, Camel, Star of East, Sheep, Angel Cookie Cutters Hand Made in the USA from Tin Plated Steel
  • High-Quality Set of Tin-Plated Steel Cookie Cutters - Foose cookie cutters are manufactured from tin plated heavy-duty tested and certified food-grade steel. This cookie cutter set features rolled edges that make it easy to grip without hurting your hands and sharp bottom for precise cutting
  • Versatile & Easy to Maintain- Our cookie cutters are used for cutting cookies, pastries, dough, fondant, vegetables, English muffins, shaping ravioli pasta, and more. Gently wash by hand with warm soapy water, avoid using anything abrasive to scrub, and dry with a cloth promptly to prevent rust. Do not leave them in a sink full of water, or they will rust
  • Versatile, Modern & Unique Cookie Cutters – Let your creative juices flow! This set of Nativity cookie cutters is ideal for making themed cookies, soft foods, bread, sandwiches, cookie dough, cheese, fruits, and craft clays. Ideal for special occasions and festivities, holidays, baby showers and as a hobby
  • Sturdy and Precise Cookie Cutter Built to Last- These insect shaped cookie cutters are made of sturdy heavy-duty tin-plated steel. Dimensions: 5.75 in Joseph, 4.5 in Mary, 2 in Manger, 4 in Camel, 2.75 in Star of East, 3 in Sheep, 4.25 in Angel
  • Family Owned & American Made – We have been making cookie cutters right here in Pleasant Valley, Missouri since 2016! Family-owned and operated with good old fashion business values. We offer quality products, fast shipping, and great customer service! Reach out to us anytime
Rank No. #17
Christian Fish and Cross Cookie Cutter
  • Food Safe Material
  • Superior Quality
  • Strong Wall Thicknesses
  • Sharp Cutting Edges
  • Durable and Reusable
Rank No. #18
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters 3-Piece Cross Cookie Cutter Set with Recipe Booklet, Holy Cross, Extra Large Cross, Fancy Cross
  • Perfect for making cookies and treats for baptisms, christenings, and holy days
  • Made in the USA; manufactured in America with certified food safe American steel
  • For over 30 years the Clark Family has specialized in original designs for creative baking
  • Cut, mold and decorate themed shapes for any holiday, party or event
  • Create and make fun shapes with cookie dough, fondant, biscuits, brownies, cakes, or craft clay
SaleRank No. #19
Rank No. #20
Ann Clark Cookie Cutters Holy Cross Cookie Cutter, 4.25"
  • The Cross Cookie Cutter is a lovely shape to use for all sorts of Christian celebrations
  • Made in the USA; Manufactured in America with certified food safe American steel
  • Variety; For over 30 years the Clark Family has specialized in original designs for creative baking
  • Baking and Party Supplies; Cut, mold and decorate themed shapes for any holiday, party or event
  • Create; Make fun shapes with cookie dough, fondant, biscuits, brownies, cakes, or craft clay

Last update on 2021-10-03 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

We’ve made a buying guide of top 10 Christian Cookie Cutters for our consumer to review. The reports above show ratings of the best overal, best cheap Christian Cookie Cutters to buy in 2020.

If you think there is mislead information on any products and services, feel free to contact our experts at any time.